Coaching, Culture, and Comebacks - ‘Next Goal Wins’ Film Review
by William Lindus
"Next Goal Wins" dives into the heartwarming yet familiar territory of underdog sports stories, but it struggles to emerge from the shadow of the popular Apple TV+ series, "Ted Lasso." The film, based on both a true story and a 2014 documentary of the same name, chronicles the journey of coach Thomas Rongen, played by Michael Fassbender. Rongen, dismissed from the American soccer team after failing to place at the World Cup, finds redemption in leading the American Samoa team, known for their staggering 31-0 loss to Australia, towards unexpected victories.
Director Taika Waititi brings his unique flair to the narrative, casting Fassbender as a gruff coach who initially resents his assignment in American Samoa. The humor veers towards heartfelt quirkiness, but never quite settles into the pocket that Waititi found in previous projects. When the humor hits, it hits, but when it falls short, it lands with a thud. Waititi's own role as a narrating American Samoan Priest, though intended to add a local perspective, ends up feeling more like a distraction than an enhancement to the storyline.
There is nothing wrong with Fassbender’s performance, but his character is the least interesting aspect of the film - a shame since he is both the POV character and the axis around which this film rotates.It was also frustrating to see Elizabeth Moss show up in this film with so little to do; she helps fill in some of Fassbender’s backstory, and serves as a catalyst for a few key moments of his development, but could have been replaced by a cardboard cutout for any other scene she appears in - a crime for someone of her talent to be so utterly wasted.
If the film has a bright spot, it is through its ensemble of soccer players, particularly Kaimana's portrayal of Jaiyah, a transwoman who becomes the soul of the story. Her portrayal is a win for trans representation, even if a particular scene that involves deadnaming - and the subsequent scene that is meant to offer redemption for this act - are clunky in their delivery. The culture of the island, seen through the lovable antics and foibles of her teammates, provide moments to grasp on to, of levity, of joy, of humanity. However, these vibrant characters are not fully explored, often reduced to mere stepping stones in Rongen's personal journey, which, while intriguing, lacks depth on screen.
"Next Goal Wins" caters to those who enjoy heartening tales of overcoming adversity, even if it doesn't quite offer a fresh perspective on this well-trodden path. It might not be the first choice for a theatrical experience, but it will eventually fit comfortably as a feel-good family movie for a cozy night in. Despite its challenges, the film's real-life inspiration and moments of genuine connection make it a decent at times, if frustrating at others, addition to the sports-comedy genre.
2.5 out of 5 Bear Paws